Adult Content Warning

This work could have adult content. If you continue, you have agreed that you are willing to see such content.

If you accept cookies from our site and you choose "Yes, Continue", you will not be asked again during this session (that is, until you close your browser). If you log in you can store your preference and never be asked again.

  1. If I Had to Do it All Again by

    Fandoms: Red Dead Redemption (Video Games)  

    24 Dec 2025

    Tags
    Summary

    After four years of deliberating, struggling, and doubting, Arthur had finally made the decision. He was going to come back to you and Isaac. And stay.
    But instead of an emotional reunion and the reveal of his decision, you were both faced with a new reality and danger, when you were nearly killed by robbers.
    As if that wasn’t enough to jolt Arthur into reality, another shocking revelation presents itself, something that he wasn’t planning on.
    And now that it isn’t safe for you, he has to make a decision that he never expected to make.
    To return to the gang, and take you with him.

    This story is now complete.

    Language:
    English
    Words:
    554,613
    Chapters:
    53/53
    Comments:
    466
    Kudos:
    501
    Bookmarks:
    72
    Hits:
    20,982